Other contemporary forms of utilitarianism mirror the forms of consequentialism outlined below. This statement does have its positives and negatives. The child goes to university, becomes the leader of the world and eradicates poverty. What kind of world is being saved if murderers are allowed to decide when and if murder is justified and then go free? A basic tenet of liberalism is the fact that an action may well be considered good, even if it doesn't yield the expected outcome, if the methods followed to achieve the same were good. In Discourses, Machiavelli becomes to extols the… 1981 Words 8 Pages well as being tasked with their welfare.
For, the end justifies the means. Thanks for your thoughts in this thread. Get one and read it. However, the author sincerely hopes that in reading his words, you gain some insight into Machiavellian issues, as well as the engaging and sometimes contentious practice of municipal governance and campaigning. All of us wanted to be successful in a right way but sometimes we thought that we must do a thing through evil or bad way but we forced ourselves not to do it. As Catholics, we know this already.
Be careful what you want, because you might get it. The British decided not to take any defensive action which would inform the Germans the code had been broken. On his account, the agent should choose the sort of life that will, on the whole, produce the best overall effects. It do … es not matter whether these methods are legal or illegal, fair or foul, kind or cruel, truth or lies, democratic or dictatorial, good or evil. The goodness of the intention then reflects the balance of the good and evil of these consequences, with no limits imposed upon it by the nature of the act itself—even if it be, say, the breaking of a promise or the execution of an innocent man. For example, that participating in a crime can matter, even if the crime would have been committed anyway, or would even have been worse, without the agent's participation.
You can use bad or immoral methods as long as you accomplish something good by using them. God did not simply create the world, populate it with people, and then leave them to muddle through on their own with no oversight from Him. By itself, it might be reprehensible. Legitimate public authority has the right and duty to inflict punishment proportionate to the gravity of the offense. The action revolves around the opinions, perceptions, reason and logic of twelve diverse characters that are tasked with pronouncing the guilt or innocence of a young man accused of patricide. The best argument for rule-consequentialism is that it does a better job than its rivals of matching and tying together our moral convictions, as well as offering us help with our moral disagreements and uncertainties.
Capital Punishment: Does the End Justify the Means? It is for them alone to point out what we ought to do, as well as to determine what we shall do. He devoted himself to the military profession and he rose to the rank of Praetor — a magistrate — of Syracuse. There are also differences as to how absolute these moral rules are. Of course, the family of the dead patient and the legal authorities might see the matter differently. The circumstances alone will determine the specific actions he will need to take to do this. They can be left justified, right justified, centred or fully justified, meaning both edges of the paragraphs … are straight.
However, consequentialism and virtue ethics need not be entirely antagonistic. No one before had ever suggested cruelty could be used in a creative way for the greater good. This essay will explain the doctrine of the ends justifies the means while showing examples of both positive and negative application outcomes. There are always motivations to do what is wrong, in order to gain something. Machiavelli's moral philosophy is deeply embedded in the present day justice administration.
Of course, when these actions affect the rights or very lives of others, they cannot always be seen as right or moral. Agathocles made a deal with its general to halt his attacks against Syracuse while Agathocles took control of the city from inside. Although some experiences may be unfavorable sometimes, anyway relax and never worry. Lying and fraud are commonplace. In practice, this equates to adhering to rule consequentialism when one can only reason on an intuitive level, and to act consequentialism when in a position to stand back and reason on a more critical level.
The gullible Giovanni even lodged Oliverotto in his own house, where Oliverotto hosted a banquet to which he invited the governing politicians and well-to-do citizens of Fermo. Should we unconditionally accept this doctrine? For them, fighting injustice was just a means towards an end. Any mention of a brand or other trademarked entity is for the purposes of education, entertainment, or parody. By analysing these three aspects, the evidence provided will evaluate whether the end does justify the means of this method. If the steps to the end were good then it justifies but if it was bad then it does not justify. The goods that serve as criteria of morality are collective or public, in contrast, for instance, to individual happiness or well-being.