Sampling Process and Sample Size 4. Conclusion of the Student This study stimulated my thinking about the value of music therapy as a complementary treatment for postoperative patients in general. This work represents one of many cases out there when researchers fail to conduct necessary investigations into the nature of the data they obtained for analysis. Perhaps obtaining permission to administer the survey during these meetings would have been possible. A research question is a statement of the specific query the researcher wants to answer, to address the research problem Polit, Beck and Hungler, 2001.
The content of the paper is right on track. Statistically speaking, the requisites of conducting analysis on a set of data include cleaning the data, and classifying the same that is according to its right distribution , so that the results will. Using the Sullivan Emotional Intelligence Scale, a 12-week emotional intelligence program was administered to the students p. Research Critique Sur Educational Research Critique What is the research design of the article by Friedel and Rudd? The research was done as a longitudinal study. I also have an interest in music, so I thought this article particular would be interesting to read and critique.
Scales were administered in a number of environmental settings: classrooms, gymnasiums, practice fields, and offices. The study appears to have been an exploratory approach to a topic that is new and not yet explored, characteristics of charter schools. Each study analysis will be 750-1,000 words and submitted in one document. Review of the Literature For this research article, the literature review mentioned the databases used in search for other relevant articles e. I left it as is for you to look at.
When any type of crack in the way we care for patients as nurses is perceived, often a theory is offered to expand patient care and better their outcomes. Here are a few tips that you can glean out of reading samples. Quantitative Research Article Critique This paper is an academic critique of an article written by Lautrette, et al. It is possible, therefore, that antipsychotic-induced diabetes results from chemical damage to the pancreas. That is a testament to the study and the formulas used to analyze the data, that the methods and results are applicable today as they were then.
The concepts used in the study are consistent with the category of care of patients and families only. Formal purpose statement is included. The numerous potential threats to internal validity need to be addressed and minimized where possible. With regard to coaching level, 25 0. The study focused on whether or not evidence-based practices in pain management practices in nursing homes were being utilized to manage and assess persistent pain in the geriatric population.
Data collection was done twice a third time if participant was not discharged— though Time 3 was not used in the findings because of certain limitations. This assignment uses a grading rubric. Ethical standards 20 10% Compare and contrast the ethical standards described or implied in each article. Overall, the study was a good-read and useful for use in my future clinical practice, but planning of the study needed to be more solid, in order, for other healthcare providers to be able to trust the validity and relevance of the study. They did not limit themselves to depend upon just the word of the staff alone.
Of 12 patients who were restarted on clozapine, 9 developed hyperglycemia again. They found that anxiety state was not significantly affected—increase or decrease—by the complementary music therapy, but pain control and environmental noise satisfaction was increased with use of the therapy. The analysis showed there were no significant differences between male and female coaches in overall leadership behaviors. The gathered is critical when creating a marketing qualitative research critique or when critiquing a qualitative research in psychology. Sampling Process and Sample Size 20 10% Compare and contrast the sampling process and size for each article.
One thing that was not discussed in this paper is the literature review. Were they any threats to external validity or internal validity? Need Help with Your Critique Writing? This paper is a critique of several different aspects of the research study including: data collection… 4724 Words 19 Pages there is a need for the obese Type 2 diabetics T2D to make changes in their lifestyle, Whittemore et al. The internal consistency for each section was calculated: 0. It narrows the purpose of the study to focus on the methodological quality of published quantitative educational reports. There is a high level of clinical relevance to the study and the field of nursing.
In a survey of diabetes associated with clozapine, glycemic control improved after clozapine was stopped in 78% of individuals who developed diabetes; 62% of these patients no longer required hypoglycemic drugs. Research Question and Hypothesis The investigators did not develop a hypothesis, but wanted to answer a specific question. In this review, the first 19 items on the reference list are reviewed. The glucose isotope was then infused for 120 minutes for the nondiabetic participants and was extended up to 180 minutes for the diabetic participants. Nursing theory is an idea or intuition based on perceived or needed improvements in nursing care or patient outcomes. For example, what were the protections put into place to protect human subjects or personal demographic data? The strength of the article lies in its methodology. In most cases it is assumed that at post graduate level, the students and supervisors need to be au fit with full spectrum of the research strategies and be in a position to link the appropriate design to some specific research objectives and question.
This methodology was mentioned as a possible area of controversy later in the article. This paper will critically appraise sections of the article in order to gain an in depth understanding. Problem Statement The authors identified the problem from the onset in a clear and comprehensible manner. Quantitative and qualitative research design: Global Management Journal; Jun Vol. Provide a rationale for your opinions and explain how each research methodology can be used to support a change in practice.